Adjudicators

The Concern Debates would not happen without our amazing team of volunteers across the country.

Getting started

Among our family of volunteers are the adjudicators. There are three adjudicators at each debate: one chief and two assistants. They mark students according to the Concern Debates marking sheet.

We are always looking for new adjudicators to join our amazing network. Generally, adjudicators will attend one debate per month during the school year, but they are free to adjudicate at as few or as many debates as they wish.

No expertise is required to become an adjudicator but an open mind is essential. You must be able to see both sides of an argument and be able to give constructive, positive feedback.

Full training is provided for each volunteer adjudicator and Concern will happily provide a reference for each volunteer who participates.

When a Debate is happening in your area, you will be contacted by us to check if you are free to adjudicate. If you are then available to adjudicate, Concern will send you all the details of the debate, such as venue and motion. Debates generally begin at 8pm and are over by 9pm.

How are debates adjudicated?

After the open forum session, the chief adjudicator will give some feedback on the debate, going over various parts of the marking sheet and offering advice for future debates.

They will then announce that the motion has been carried (won by the proposition) or defeated (won by the opposition).

Will I need to undergo Garda Vetting?

As of 2019, all Concern Debates Adjudicators must be Garda Vetted in line with Concern’s new safeguarding guidelines. Your Garda Vetting will last for three years with Concern. When you complete the volunteer sign up form, Concern will add your basic details to the An Garda Síochána’s online e-Vetting portal. You will receive an email communication inviting you to log on and enter additional information required by the National Vetting Bureau to complete the vetting process.

You can also request a manual form from Concern to complete and Concern can enter this information into the e-Vetting system on your behalf.

When you do this, Concern will submit the application to the National Vetting Bureau. The Bureau will conduct the check and Concern will receive a report of criminal conviction histories of those relevant volunteers (or not as the case may be).

For more information on the process, please contact [email protected]

Adjudicators at the 2018 Concern Debates Final. Photo: Ruth Medjber / Concern Worldwide.
Adjudicators at the 2018 Concern Debates Final. Photo: Ruth Medjber / Concern Worldwide.
Concern Debates 2017-2018 Semi Final Adjudicators (L-R Emmanuel George, Sandra Marie Donohoe, Marie Griffin. Photo: Ruth Medjber / Concern Worldwide.
Concern Debates 2017-2018 Semi Final Adjudicators. Photo: Ruth Medjber / Concern Worldwide.
Adjudicators watch on as a debate takes place. Photo: Concern Worldwide.
Adjudicators watch on as a debate takes place. Photo: Concern Worldwide.

This is also an excellent opportunity to hear the views of young people on serious issues and to gain a deeper knowledge and understanding of the world.

Geraldine Carroll - Concern’s Schools and Youth Programme Administrator

Why sign up as an adjudicator? 

Here are the top three reasons to get involved with the Concern Debates.

Open/Close

Knowledge

Open/Close

Interested in politics, current affairs, and international development? Concern carefully chooses motions to encourage critical thinking on complex issues relating to development, poverty, justice, and human rights. Through adjudicating you will get the chance to listen to fascinating viewpoints from a youth point of view on some of the most contentious issues facing our world today.

Open/Close

Skills

Open/Close
Open/Close

Empower young people

Open/Close

Our adjudicators have their say

If you need any more convincing, our wonderful past and present adjudicators got together to say why they got involved in the Concern Debates and how it has left an impact on them.

Adjudicator resources

We have plenty of resources for people interested in adjudicating our debates. You'll find everything from timekeeping sheets to speech templates in the list below.

Download
Download
Download
Download
Download
Download

Join our team

If you like what you’ve heard so far, please sign up below and a Concern member of staff will be in touch with further information.

Support our Liberia water appeal

  • A shocking 90% of people in Liberia have limited access to safe water

  • We’re repairing and building wells to bring clean water to more people

  • The need is huge and we need your help to reach more communities

Support this appeal
Share your concern